What is the best soap - let’s break it down

Posted by YDG Collaborator on


Washing your hands is the first step towards infection prevention, we all know that too well by now. Soaps are one of the most efficient ways of removing pathogens from our hands, not just Covid-19 but a range of dangerous things that can be harmful for our health. 

Yet so many questions boggle our minds when it comes to choosing the right soap - what kind of soap? Is there a soap that works best against bacteria and germs? Bar or liquid? Are all soaps the same, anyway? Look no further, let’s get right to it and we’ll help you uncover some of these answers. 

Moisturising Hand Wash

With all due credits to globalisation for such extensive choices, but don’t you think it’s a little amusing how we now find ourselves standing in the soap section of our local supermarket overwhelmed by the sheer options available in hand soaps. In the soap kingdom, however, the distinctions are fairly simple and one such distinction is - regular soap or anti-bacterial. What purpose does either of them serve and whether it makes any difference? 

Regular vs Antibacterial Soap

Today we find antibacterial soaps commonplace in both homes and offices, it’s no surprise that it is so. The name says anti-bacterial, surely it must have an upper hand over regular soaps when it comes to preventing bacteria. Surprise, surpise, they don’t. Your humble ‘regular soap’ is capable of much more than you expect of it

The difference between regular soaps and anti-bacterial soaps lies in the fact that the latter obviously contains additional chemicals. Also,  they both work in different ways to achieve essentially the same result, that is - removing icky pathogens and dirt from your hands.

Regular soaps work by  sticking to the virus. Long story short it helps to ‘break apart’ the virus. Anti Bacterial on the other hand kills the pathogens. So, really, by hook or by crook, all roads lead to a germ-free Rome. Anti-bacterial might just be tad bit quicker. 

Although beware, many anti bacterial soaps contain harmful ingredients such as triclosan and triclocarban, which can be an irritant and quite frankly toxic. In 2016, US FDA (Food and Drug Administration) even banned the chemical, yet we might still find this in hoards of products being sold in India. 

Among the antibacterial and regular soaps there are further two teams to pit against each other, namely, Liquid vs. Bar Soaps

Liquid vs Bar Soap

Facing another crossroad in the soap section aisle? Fear not, let's bust some more myths.

Bar soaps are ancient, they’ve been around longer than any of us but liquid soaps, now those are the new kids in town. Well, as new as 1865 can be. This was the year William Shepphard is said to have gotten the first patent for liquid soap. Soaps only got more complicated and varied from then on. 

A little fun trivia - India has a history of using a certain berry known as, well, soapberries. Or if you’re into the science side of things then Sapindus which literally translates to Soap (sapon/sap) and India (indus). The berries contain saponin - the natural soap ingredient that does the job of lifting the grease and dirt off your skin.

Anyway, back to the question of the hour - liquid or bar? If I were to cut to the chase I’ll have to say they’re both good to go, as long as you know it’s sourced right and are aware of what goes into it.

Bar soaps are said to be less moisturising in comparison but that’s solely because a majority of the bar soaps available in the market have high pH levels. Moisturising handwashes are typically liquid soaps. 

Organic Hand Wash

A lot of times we doubt the hygiene factor when it comes to sharing a bar of soap. We fear that sharing a soap is much like sharing a spoon with a stranger, but that’s not entirely true. It’s a pretty legitimate concern though, if you can leave bacteria on the surfaces you touch then it’s possible you do the same on a bar of soap. They are constantly exposed to the environment it’s kept in, so is there a chance of germ contamination? Not really. Family members living on the same bar, definitely something? Nope, no contamination.  

There is something known as surfactants in your soap bar. Surfactants are compounds that help to physically remove any germs thriving on your hand, as soon as you apply water to it. The germs are supposed to wash away into the drain. Besides, if these are bacteria coming from you then they really won’t cause you any harm (remember, there are both good and bad bacteria, and we are constantly carrying the good ones in and around us). When it comes to family, the fact remains that you are already sharing enough and more microorganisms with each other. 

Ultimately it all comes down to How you wash your hands and how long you scrub them for, and that makes all the difference. Bars and Liquids work just as efficiently to remove unwanted things from your hands. And get this, ALL soaps can put up a tough fight against Covid-19 if you wash properly. 

Below is a step-by-step process for effective handwashing.

  • Wet hands with running water
  • Apply enough soap to cover wet hands
  • Scrub all surfaces of the hands – including back of hands, between fingers and under nails – for at least 20 seconds.
  • Rinse thoroughly with running water
  • Dry hands with a clean cloth or single-use towel

In Conclusion

The verdict is that you should choose your soap according to what you want out of it, besides a germ free wash cause they all guarantee that anyway. The only things that should make you eliminate a soap  are these harmful ingredients -Triclosan, Parabens, synthetic dyes/colourants, Propylene Glycol, Glycol Distearate (the thing that makes your antiseptic soap ‘shine’). The best natural hand wash doesn't contain any of those nasties. If it’s moisturisation, lather and convenience you value, go for a liquid hand wash. Our very own Natural Hand Wash might just be what you’re looking for . If you value savings and don’t want bottles then bars are the way to go. 

Natural Hand Wash

A little tip from our side - just ensure they’re sourced right and are safe for the environment, if so, then they are a 100% safe for you.

all natural All Purpose Cleaner antibacterial antiseptic baby safe bacteria biodegradable Chemical Free Children clean Clean Air Cleaning Tips Dishwashing Liquid handwash lavender liquid handwash Organic regular soap soap soap bar vegan

← Older Post Newer Post →

The Clean Slate

2022 resolutions air freshner Air Purifiers all natural all natural body wash All Natural Surface Cleaner All Purpose Cleaner Aloe Vera Plant aluminium foil animal animal love antibacterial antiseptic Appliances aroma Asiatic Lion Asthma Asthma in children athletics baby care baby friendly baby friendly floor cleaner baby laundry detergent baby safe baby safe floor cleaner Baby Safe Floor Disinfectant baby-safe bacteria baking soda bath bombs bathroom cleaner bathroom cleaning beauty without bunnies bedding Bengal Tiger Best Indoor Plants for Health Best smelling floor cleaner India binge watch biodegradable Bisphenol A (BPA) Black Buck bleach-free Bleaching Blender body wash body wash benefits body wash vs bar soap calm candle candle making car fragrance carbon emissions carbon footprint Changes Chemical Free chemical-free child friendly Childhood asthma Children chocolate bark Chores Christmas Christmas Crafts Christmas Tree Citrus clean Clean Air clean dishes Clean House clean resolutions cleaner Cleaners cleaning cleaning & society cleaning 2022 Cleaning Desk Tips cleaning products cleaning resolutions cleaning shows Cleaning Tips cleaning tools cleaning your tools cloth conditioner cloth mask clothes coffee coffee stain cornflour COVID-19 covid-19 care cruelty free customairfreshener Declutter deep cleaning detangling brush detergent dettol Dirty Dishes Dishwash Dishwasher Dishwashing Liquid Dishwashing Liquid 500ml disinfectant disposable mask diwali DIY diy candles DIY Hacks Dog floor cleaner Dog Safe Floor Cleaner dog shampoo dry skin dry skin winterw dushhera break Easy Peasy Crafts Easy to Care Eco friendly eco friendly all purpose cleaner eco friendly home eco friendly swaps eco-friendly gifting ecofriendly environment essential oil candles essential oils Experiment fabric conditioner fabric softener India Fertilizers festive season Finances fitness Flame Retardants floor cleaner floor cleaning liquid food waste Formaldehyde fragrance fresh fresh home Gardening gender bias gender inequality gender inequality in family gender inequality in home gift wrapping gifting candles granite Grape Ivy green cleaning Greenery hand sanitiser hand wash hand washing handmade handwash Hard Stains hard water hardwood harmful chemicals healthy coat. healthy fur herbal body wash home home decor home makeover house cleaning household chores housework how to clean hydration Indoor plants irritation-free skin itching jasmine ketchup Kids friendly kitchen hacks Kitchen Solutions Koparo koparo news Kopraan laundry laundry day laundry detergent laundry detergent for babies laundry detergent liquid laundry liquid detergenyt lavender lemon juice Lessons life skills lifestyle & wellness Lifestyle and Wellness Lint roller liquid handwash liquid soap Lizol Low maintenance marble floor cleaner Mask mattress mattress cleaning Microwave Minimal watering plants Mixer Mobile mobile phones moisturise moisturizing and hydrating shampoo Money Money Plant multipurpose cleaner National Endangered Species Day natrural Natural natural ingredients natural body wash Natural cleaners Natural Dishwashing Liquid natural disinfectant natural dog product natural floor cleaner Natural Floor Cleaner India natural freshner natural handwash Natural Laundry Liquid natural oil natural product natural soap natural solutions nature Net Zero Target netflix New New Name New Year new year goals new year resolutions no chemicals No Toxins Non toxic cleaning products Non Toxic Floor Cleaner For Babies Non-toxic nonstick pan nonstick utensils organic organic body wash Organic cleaners Organic Dishwashing Liquid organic freshner Organic Produce organise organising shows Organizing Paint parenting pet allergies pet care Pet friendly Pet friendly floor cleaner Pet friendly floor cleaner India Pet grooming pet safe Pet Safe Floor Cleaner pet-safe peta peta certified pH Balanced formula Phosphates Phthalates plan plant plant based plant based ingredients plant-based ingredients Pocket Money potpourri prime video recycle regular soap Remove Hard Stains resolutions rose rough skin in winters safe safe clothes safe dishes Safe for pets safe handwash safety salt sanitizer Santa Claus Savings scent Science Seeds shoe cleaning shoes shower routine side effects of chemical cleaners silver silver cutlery silver jewellery silverware skincare skincare routine smell smells good Snake Plant sneaker cleaning sneakerhead soap soap bar soft hands Soil Sulfates summer surfactants sustainability sustainable sustainable gifting Therapeutic tiles tip for cleaning masks Tips to do list Tomatoes toxic ingredients toxin-free toxins toy cleaning toys Triclosan tuberose tv shows utensil cleaner liquid vagan vegan vegan cleaners vegan diet vegan shower gel Vegetables vim vim chemicals vim dishwashing gel vim gel ingredients wall Wash your pet water water conservation waterbottle WFH desk white shoes white sneakers White Vinegar wildlife wildlife photography winter season winter skin wood furniture